CN
“Top pick for health-focused users who want clinical-grade body composition data”
Is the Withings Body Comp Smart Scale worth it?
The Withings Body Comp Smart Scale is a top pick with a 8.7/10 consensus score across 3 expert reviews. Experts highlight 17 health metrics including nerve health and vascular age — unmatched depth and multi-frequency bia for segmental body composition (arms, legs, torso). Wirecutter says: "The most advanced smart scale you can buy without a prescription" Best for: Health-focused households, Fitness enthusiasts, Medical monitoring.
Must Buy3 Expert Reviews
Price Range
$220–$230
$220-$230 listMulti-frequency BIA3 expert sources
Check price →Affiliate link — we earn a commission at no extra cost to you
Withings Body Comp Smart Scale
NM
Nicholas Miles · Editor-in-Chief & Methodology Owner
Bathroom Scales
Expert consensus
How we score08.7/1010
3 expert sources · 3 quoted
3 quoted sources with published scores
- Forbes Health 8.5/10
- CNET 8.8/10
- Wirecutter 9/10
Expert Consensus across 3 sources
Updated:Editorial consensus score: SmartHomeExplorer's synthesis of the 3 published expert reviews listed on this page. Not a user rating.
“The most advanced smart scale you can buy without a prescription”
Key Features
- ✓ Multi-frequency BIA
- ✓ Nerve health detection
- ✓ Vascular age
- ✓ 17 metrics
Best For
Health-focused householdsFitness enthusiastsMedical monitoring
Withings Body Comp Smart Scale vs. the alternatives
How the Withings Body Comp Smart Scale stacks up against other Health options on price, expert consensus, and ecosystem support.
| Product | Price | Consensus | Works With | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Withings Body Comp Smart ScaleThis page | $220-$230 | 8.7/10 | — | Must Buy |
| Renpho Elis Aspire Smart Scale | $45-$55 | 7.4/10 | — | Recommended |
| Eufy Smart Scale P3 | $55-$65 | 7.8/10 | — | Recommended |
| Garmin Index S2 Smart Scale | $190-$200 | 8.1/10 | — | Recommended |
The Withings Body Comp Smart Scale ($220-$230 list) earns a 8.7/10 expert consensus across 3 sources, versus the Renpho Elis Aspire Smart Scale at $45-$55 list (7.4/10 consensus).
What Experts Agree On
What Experts Love
- ✓ 17 health metrics including nerve health and vascular age — unmatched depth
- ✓ Multi-frequency BIA for segmental body composition (arms, legs, torso)
- ✓ Syncs with Apple Health, Google Fit, Samsung Health, and 100+ apps
- ✓ Auto-recognizes up to 8 household members
- ✓ Color display shows trends directly on the scale
Common Criticisms
- ✗ $199 price is steep compared to basic smart scales
- ✗ Nerve health readings can be inconsistent with dry feet
- ✗ No Bluetooth-only mode — requires WiFi for full functionality
What The Experts Say
FO
“The gold standard of consumer smart scales for anyone serious about health tracking”
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the Withings Body Comp Smart Scale worth it?
The Withings Body Comp Smart Scale earns a 8.7/10 consensus score across 3 expert sources and is rated "Must Buy". At $220-$230, it is best for Health-focused households. Wirecutter is among the named sources behind that consensus.
How much does the Withings Body Comp Smart Scale cost?
The Withings Body Comp Smart Scale is priced at $220-$230. With a 8.7/10 score from 3 expert reviews and a "Must Buy" rating, that price represents strong value relative to the ~7.5/10 average for Health products. Prices shift often, so check the live figure before buying.
Who is the Withings Body Comp Smart Scale best for?
The Withings Body Comp Smart Scale is best for Health-focused households, Fitness enthusiasts, Medical monitoring. Experts rate it "Must Buy" with a 8.7/10 consensus across 3 sources.
How does the Withings Body Comp Smart Scale compare to other Health options?
Among the Health products we have aggregated, the Withings Body Comp Smart Scale ranks above average with a 8.7/10 score. CNET adds: "Top pick for health-focused users who want clinical-grade body composition data"
What are the best alternatives to the Withings Body Comp Smart Scale?
If the Withings Body Comp Smart Scale ($220-$230, 8.7/10) is not the right fit, the closest alternatives in Health are Eufy Smart Scale P3, Garmin Index S2 Smart Scale. Compare them on price, ecosystem support, and expert consensus to find your match.
What are the pros and cons of the Withings Body Comp Smart Scale?
The main strengths of the Withings Body Comp Smart Scale are 17 health metrics including nerve health and vascular age — unmatched depth and multi-frequency bia for segmental body composition (arms, legs, torso). The most-cited downside is $199 price is steep compared to basic smart scales. Overall, 3 expert sources rate it "Must Buy" with a 8.7/10 consensus score.
Decided on the Withings Body Comp Smart Scale?
$220-$230 listMulti-frequency BIA3 expert sources
Check price →Affiliate link — we earn a commission at no extra cost to you
Hyperice Normatec Elite Legs
Check price
Mito Red MitoMEGA 2.0
Check price
Ray-Ban Meta (Gen 2) Wayfarer Smart AI Glasses
Check price
Oura Ring 4
Check price
Soundcore Sleep A30 by Anker
Check price
Carex Day-Light Elite
Check price
Featured in these buying guides
See how the Withings Body Comp Smart Scale ranks against the full field in our Health buying guides.
Shop similar on Amazon
Comparable Health picks you can buy today — each link goes straight to its current Amazon listing.
Sponsored
Ready for game day?
Bose Lifestyle Ultra Soundbar
See it on Amazon
Velieta 24" Outdoor Beverage Refrigerator
See it on Amazon
Sponsored listings from Amazon’s Sponsored Products for Creators program, kept apart from our reviews and rankings. How we make money
Sources & Methodology
This review aggregates 3 independent expert reviews into a single consensus score. See how we build consensus scores.
Expert review sources cited on this page:
- Wirecutter
- CNET
- Forbes Health
Affiliate disclosure: SmartHomeExplorer.com participates in the Amazon Associates program. We earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.This consensus review is based on 3 independent expert reviews — we did not test this product ourselves. Always verify current prices and availability before purchasing.
Independence notice: Smart Home Explorer is an independent publication. Withings and other product names, logos, and brands referenced on this page are the property of their respective owners and are used for identification purposes only. This review is not sponsored by, affiliated with, or endorsed by Withings or any other manufacturer named in this article.